Every year the Paper St. Coffee Cafes bring a specially tailored lineup of holiday drinks capturing the taste of the season and only available for a limited time. Each Cafe has a unique menu - the 2025 Holiday drinks are: 

Cresskill NJ Holiday Cafe Drink Lineup

✨ The Sugar Cookie Latte —

Our Sugar Cookie Latte is built around comfort, nostalgia, and a little holiday fun, crafted the Paper Street way.

☕ What’s Inside

Every cup starts with a Paper Street espresso, rich and balanced, paired with your milk of choice. We add vanilla syrup for a smooth sweetness and mix in one crushed sugar cookie to deliver that true cookie flavor — because the best results come from the real thing.

It’s topped with our light cold foam and finished with two sugar cookies for a crisp, festive touch.

💫 

The Sugar Cookie Latte tastes like the best parts of the season — warm, familiar, and a little nostalgic — without ever feeling overly sweet or heavy. It’s a simple idea done well, perfect for mornings on the go, mid-day resets, or whenever you want a cup that feels like a small holiday moment.

 

✨ The Eggnog Latte — A Holiday Classic, Elevated

Some drinks define the season, and the Eggnog Latte is one of them. Rich, and unmistakably festive, this version takes everything you love about traditional eggnog and blends it with the depth of Paper Street espresso for a clean, elevated holiday experience.

☕ What’s Inside

We start with Paper Street espresso, balanced and bold enough to stand up to the creaminess of eggnog. From there, we mix in your preferred milk to keep the texture light, smooth, and customizable.

Each cup is finished with a dusting of cinnamon powder and a cinnamon stick—simple touches that bring warm spice and a true holiday aroma.

❄️ The Holiday S’mores Latte — A Winter Treat, Toasted Just for You

The Holiday S’mores Latte features a marshmallow moment perched on top — and yes, we toast it with real fire right before serving. It’s the kind of moment that feels straight out of a winter night by the campfire.

We can technically S’mores-ify any iced latte on the menu. Choose your drink, and we’ll infuse it with marshmallow fluff, then finish it with a marshmallow topper that gets its own little campfire treatment and the perfect amount of chocolate swirl drizzle.

Cozy sweetness, toasted marshmallow magic — ready for the holidays.

 

Nashville

🍎 Apple Chai-der — Chai With an Orchard Twist

The Apple Chai-der blends spiced chai with bright apple cider for a drink that feels lively and seasonal. It’s chai with a little extra character — warm spice, crisp apple notes, and a finish that feels right at home this time of year.

☕ What’s Inside

• Chai

• Apple cider

• Milk of your choice

• Pumpkin spice seasoning + apple crisp on top

The mix of chai and cider creates a layered flavor: bold, slightly sweet, and unmistakably fall and winter. The pumpkin spice topping and apple crisp bring a bit of texture and aroma that set this drink apart.

✨ Ginger Snap Latte — Spiced, Sweet, and Snappy

The Ginger Snap Latte takes the classic latte and gives it a ginger snappy snap. It’s built with house-made ginger snap milk that carries a warm spice and molasses depth, paired with espresso for balance.

☕ What’s Inside

• Ginger snap milk

• Shot of Paper Street espresso

• Candied ginger on top

The result is a latte that’s bold, lightly spiced, and a little playful — especially with the candied ginger finish.

🎄 Candy Cane Latte — Peppermint Meets Classic Sweetness

The Candy Cane Latte brings together peppermint and white chocolate for a drink that leans bright, smooth, and festive. It’s the kind of flavor combination people look forward to during the festive season —  cheerful, and unmistakably seasonal.

☕ What’s Inside

• Peppermint

• White chocolate

• Topped with candy cane sugar sprinkle

The peppermint lifts the espresso while the white chocolate adds softness, and the candy cane sugar ties it all together with a clean holiday crunch.

 

Our Holiday drinks are always limited time - so enjoy them while they are available or visit the recipe blog to try your home barista skills.

We love seeing you in our cafés - But we know not everyone lives close to our Cresskill, NJ or Nashville, TN cafe locations and that getting to us is a journey. We hope sharing our recipes brings the joy of our drinks to your home, whether you’re a brand-new home barista or a seasoned coffee fancy pants with a style of your own. Please share your finished drink from the recipe and tag us on social—we’d love to see our recipe in action.